How to Talk to Your Co-workers About Raceby Mark Courts on 07/01/17
Seven tips for navigating this complex conversation
There isn't a more sensitive, front-running topic in the nation right now than race--it's inescapable. The topic can be emotional, all-consuming, daunting, frustrating, and irritating, but it can also liberate, educate, inspire, and unite.
The workplace is generally where egg shells are walked on when facing complex, emotional issues such as racial sensitivity. However, given today's social climate, this issue is increasingly harder to ignore or escape, even during those hours spent at work. Race is the elephant in the room.
To find out what we can do to safely address this elephant, BlackEnterprise.com reached out to Sofia Santiago, an expert in intercultural communication and co-author of the book Difficult Conversations Just for Women: Kill the Anxiety, Get What You Want. Here is her advice:
1. Start With "Why?"
Why are you having this conversation? If it's clear to all parties that the purpose is to have a respectful exchange of ideas that could end in someone saying "let's agree to disagree," a handshake, and maybe even a beer after work, then proceed. If someone is more interested in proving he or she is right and whoever disagrees is wrong, then choose to talk about a sport you both like instead.
2. Also Begin by Agreeing to Recognize Ethnic Differences
Recognizing means admitting that people from a variety ethnic groups ultimately present cultural differences; it's not the same as judging. Judging implies the belief that one group is inherently superior to others. If all participants in the conversation can agree on maintaining this approach, they'll be off to a good start.
3. Try to Understand Where the Other Person's Perspective
When it comes to racial conversations, people present varying levels of intercultural development. Bennett's Developmental Model of Intercultural Sensitivity (DMIS) lists them as follows:
- Denial: People are only able to experience differences via extremely simplistic ways (black people literally have black colored skin and Latinos like salsa).
- Defense: People tend to exaggerate the positives of their own culture, believing it is the most "evolved" and the best way to live. They have a polarized perspective; us and them.
- Minimization: People feel as if they have already arrived at intercultural sensitivity.
- Acceptance: People want to learn about other cultures, not to confirm prejudices, but to learn.
- Adaptation: At this level, people have the ability to empathize with another worldview.
- Integration: People usually have a wide repertoire of cultural perspectives they can draw upon, and they can move in and out of different cultural worldviews rather smoothly.
Just from the descriptions, it's easy to anticipate the outcome of racial conversations, once one has identified the stages at which the parties are.
4. Agree on Focusing on Content, Rather Than on the Process
Imagine that you want to have a conversation about another sensitive issue--such as gay marriage, abortion, or politics--and you don't know in advance whether the other person agrees with you or not. Now, imagine that you are quiet and like discussions that are unattached and unemotional. You like using logic to present a topic, regardless of any feelings you may have about it. In contrast, the other person likes to argue, feels passionate about the topic, is sometimes loud, highly expressive, and insists that you take a stand. He or she feels uncomfortable with silence, and if you don't reply, they interpret it as if you're holding back.
Have you noticed that I haven't even told you what each party believes, and we are already focusing on the differences approaches each has to the conversation, rather than on the issue at hand? That's what focusing on process rather than on content means.
5. Confirm the Meaning of Terms; Don't Assume They Mean the Same Thing for Each of You
Effective communicators know assuming is never a good idea, and in delicate situations, it's even more important to avoid taking definitions for granted.
6. Balance the Ethnic Backgrounds of Those in the Conversation
Imagine a group of ten black employees having a conversation about race with one white employee. Now, imagine a group of five blacks and five whites. The group dynamics will be different just because of the balance.
7. Have an Exit Line
Use exit lines to leave a conversation gracefully, like:
- "I hear you <insert the other person's name>."
- "I need some time to think about what you've said."
- "Let's resume this conversation <insert when you propose to resume the conversation, such as first thing the next morning>."
- Depending on the circumstances and who the other person is, you may choose a less firm and more collaborative approach. For instance, "How about we resume this conversation <say when>?"
What makes an exit line effective is your ability to use it before a conflict escalates
by Safon Floyd